Lump Sum or Monthly Pension: What Gets You More Money in Retirement?

senior couple enjoying retirement
Share this article:

Retirement isn’t as simple as exiting the workforce and living the life you always wanted. Before fully embracing this new chapter, you’ll need to make some key decisions—like how to receive your retirement benefits. Should you take a lump sum or monthly pension? This decision can shape your financial future.

You must consider several factors when deciding how to receive your retirement benefits. It’s not that one of these choices is “bad.” It’s usually that one of these choices is better than the other, for you. The “for you” part is important. Meaning to say, the answer may vary from person to person. 

Both options come with advantages and challenges, so you must carefully evaluate your goals, financial situation, and lifestyle preferences. Then, you can better navigate this crucial decision with confidence.

Understanding the Lump Sum Option 

A lump sum payment is a payout plan that lets you receive your entire retirement benefit upfront. While this offers flexibility and the potential for growth, it also requires careful planning and financial discipline to ensure your savings last.

Pros

  • Immediate access to funds – You get your money all at once, allowing you to use it as you see fit.
  • Flexibility in investing – You can invest the money in opportunities that suit your goals and risk tolerance. You can grow your wealth even in retirement.
  • Simplified finances – You won’t need to rely on regular payments from your pension provider.

Cons

  • Requires discipline – Managing a large sum demands careful budgeting to avoid overspending.
  • Comes with investment risks – Market fluctuations can affect the value of your investments.
  • Funds may run out – Without proper planning, you may deplete your savings too soon.

Understanding the Monthly Pension Option 

The monthly pension option provides a steady, predictable income over time to ensure your financial stability throughout retirement. It’s a straightforward choice if you prefer consistent payments without the need to manage large sums of money.

Pros

  • Reliable income – Monthly payouts guarantee a consistent paycheck, simplifying budgeting for your daily needs.
  • Peace of mind – This option reduces the risk of running out of money during your lifetime.
  • No investment management – There’s no burden of handling and growing a particular investment.

Cons

  • Limited flexibility – You can’t access large sums for unexpected expenses or investments.
  • Inflation risk – Fixed payments may lose value as living costs rise.
  • Minimal legacy potential – There’s often little or no money left to pass on to your heirs.

Choosing Between Lump Sum vs. Monthly Pension

The right pension plan depends on your circumstances, priorities, and financial goals. Here are some key factors to guide your choice.

Lifespan and health

If you expect a long retirement and are in good health, a monthly pension ensures a steady income for life. However, if you have health issues or a shorter life expectancy, a lump sum allows you to enjoy your pension sooner and leave a more sizeable legacy since you can pass down unused funds without being tied to the terms of a pension plan.

Investment opportunities

Are you confident in managing money or working with a trusted financial advisor? A lump sum lets you grow your wealth through investments. However, if market risks make you uneasy, a monthly pension offers peace of mind with guaranteed income.

Tax implications

With a lump sum, you may get a higher tax bill upfront because 20% automatically goes to taxes. On the other hand, monthly pensions spread the tax payments over time. Consider consulting a tax advisor to evaluate the financial impact of each option.

Retirement lifestyle goals

If you plan to make significant purchases or travel during retirement, a lump sum can help you fund these goals. Meanwhile, a monthly pension is ideal for covering regular living expenses.

Inflation

A lump sum lets you invest in options that outpace inflation. On the other hand, fixed monthly pensions may lose value over time unless they include cost-of-living adjustments.

What Gets You More Money?

To compare lump sum and monthly pension options, you may use these baseline assumptions:

  • Lump sum amount – $500,000
  • Monthly pension amount – $2,500/month
  • Lifespan assumption – 20 years in retirement
  • Investment return on lump sum – 5% annually
  • Inflation rate – 3% annually
  • Tax rate – 20% (applies equally to both options)

Now, here are three scenarios to understand how these factors influence your choice.

Scenario A: Longer lifespan (25 years) with inflation impact

If you are in good health and live long, you’ll receive $750,000 from a monthly pension over 25 years ($30,000/year). However, inflation may erode the value of fixed payments, leaving less purchasing power over time.

On the other hand, investing the lump sum at a 5% return could grow your money to about $1.7 million before taxes after 25 years. It potentially offers greater long-term value.

Scenario B: Poor investment performance (2% return)

If your lump sum earns just 2% annually, its value after 20 years would be approximately $742,000 before taxes. Meanwhile, the monthly pension would provide $600,000 over the same period. 

While the lump sum still offers a higher nominal value, the difference is minimal, given the low return rate. In such a scenario, the predictable and stable income of a monthly pension might be a safer and less stressful option, particularly if you’re concerned about market volatility or investment risks.

Scenario C: Early death (10-year lifespan)

If you live only 10 years after retirement, the monthly pension pays $300,000. In contrast, the lump sum remains yours, and even with modest growth (5% annually), it could grow to about $814,000 before taxes. This case makes the lump sum more advantageous if you want to leave a larger estate for your loved ones.

Making the Right Choice for Retirement 

Selecting a pension plan is a very important decision in retirement planning. Factors like lifespan, investment opportunities, taxes, inflation, and lifestyle goals all play a role in determining which option suits you best. While this guide serves as the foundation, consulting a financial professional for tailored advice is always wise.

It’s worth mentioning that as important as this decision is, there are dozens of additional questions and planning work that you should be evaluating inside of your finances, money management, investments, estate planning, insurance planning and cash-flow management.

As financial planners, we would be unemployed if our jobs were done after answering this one question. I share that to encourage you to meet with a sharp and wise financial planner that can help drive excellent outcomes in all sorts of areas of your financial world! 

Allow me to leave you with one example…as you amass and manage your money, what account type is best to leave your wealth for the next generation? There is a proper answer to this question and it’s not simple. That’s where a firm like Tencap shines. We specialize in complexity and financial planning and between our team we have guided and assisted thousands of clients through retirement! This is a world we know and love and we can be extremely helpful in helping you create and execute a responsible financial plan to optimize your wealth, and the next generations wealth! 

Tencap Wealth Coaching is here to help you. We’re a team set up to serve many states in the country and we are led by a Certified Financial Advisor® specializing in retirement planning and wealth management. Our goal is to help you build and secure your wealth  Investing in our advisory services means transitioning confidently with a coach, into your golden years. 

Contact us today for more information.

Disclaimer: The information contained herein should in no way be construed or interpreted as a solicitation to sell or offer to sell advisory services to any residents of any State other than the State of Utah or where otherwise legally permitted. All content is for information purposes only. It is not intended to provide any tax or legal advice or provide the basis for any financial decisions. Nor is it intended to be a projection of current or future performance or indication of future results. Moreover, this material has been derived from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy and completeness and does not purport to be a complete analysis of the materials discussed. Purchases are subject to suitability. This requires a review of an investor’s objective, risk tolerance, and time horizons. Investing always involves risk and possible loss of capital.

Nick Carrigan Standing
Nick Carrigan
Wealth Advisor |  + posts

Nick trains and develops families in creating, maintaining, and growing wealth. This includes educating clients on the science and academics of investing, comprehensive financial planning, and ongoing coaching to ensure discipline for a lifetime. Nick has seen this create incredible levels of freedom, fulfillment, and love for the families he works with.

Share this article:
Table of Contents
Recent Posts

Form CRS


Disclosure

All content is for information purposes only. It is not intended to provide any tax or legal advice or
provide the basis for any financial decisions. Nor is it intended to be a projection of current or
future performance or indication of future results.

Opinions expressed herein are solely those of Tencap Wealth Coaching and our editorial staff. The information contained in this material has been derived from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy and completeness and does not purport to be a complete analysis of the materials discussed. All information and ideas should be discussed in detail with your individual adviser prior to implementation. Advisory services are offered by Tencap Wealth Coaching, an Investment Advisor registered with the SEC. Being registered as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

  • Advisory services are offered through Tencap Wealth Coaching, a SEC Investment Advisor.

     

  • Insurance products and services are offered through Tencap Legacy, an affiliated
    company.

     

  • Tencap Wealth Coaching and Tencap Legacy are not affiliated with or endorsed by the Social Security Administration or any other government agency.
 

The information contained herein should in no way be construed or interpreted as a solicitation to
sell or offer to sell advisory services to any residents of any State other than the State of Utah or
where otherwise legally permitted.

Images and photographs are included for the sole purpose of visually enhancing the website. None of them are photographs of current or former Clients. They should not be construed as an
endorsement or testimonial from any of the persons in the photograph.

Purchases are subject to suitability. This requires a review of an investor’s objective, risk tolerance, and time horizons. Investing always involves risk and possible loss of capital.

 

Links to Other Sites

The inclusion of any link is not an endorsement of any products or services by [Firm Name]. All
links have been provided only as a convenience. These include links to websites operated by other government agencies, nonprofit organizations and private businesses. When you use one of these links, you are no longer on this site and this Privacy Notice will not apply. When you link to another website, you are subject to the privacy of that new site.

When you follow a link to one of these sites neither Tencap Wealth Coaching, nor any agency, officer, or employee of the Tencap warrants the accuracy, reliability or timeliness of any information published by these external sites, nor endorses any content, viewpoints, products, or services linked from these systems, and cannot be held liable for any losses caused by reliance on the accuracy, reliability or timeliness of their information. Portions of such information may be
incorrect or not current. Any person or entity that relies on any information obtained from these
systems do so at their own risk.

 

-Washington State Only

Tencap Wealth Coaching is an investment adviser registered in the State of Washington.
The adviser/firm may not transact business in states where it is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted from registration. Individualized responses to persons that involve either the effecting of transaction in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation, will not be made without registration or exemption. Being registered as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training.